As humans, we will naturally warm to some people more than others. However, in the workplace, preferential treatment can create real issues.
It’s quite common for employers or managers to have a better working relationship with certain members of their team. It might be that that their way of working is more akin to yours, that you’ve known them for longer, or simply that your personalities mesh better.
In fact, if pushed, most people would probably be able to identify the ‘favourites’ in their team, and in a lot of cases, this is simply an accepted fact of working life.
However, when you’re in a position of authority, it’s important to be mindful that the decisions you make are fair, and that you can justify your actions on objective grounds, as managing through gut decisions can create real animosity within your team and, in some circumstances, leave the door open for disgruntled employees to take legal action.
What is workplace favouritism?
Favouritism in the workplace occurs when an individual, usually a manager, treats one employee more favourably than the others for reasons unrelated to performance. Broadly speaking, there are two types of favouritism that employers and managers are often guilty of:
- Giving one employee perks and privileges that others don’t get; and/or
- Letting a particular employee get away with things that others wouldn’t get away with.
Whether such treatment is deliberate or not, failing to take an evenhanded approach to employee matters has the potential to destabilise your team by creating hostility and setting dangerous precedents about acceptable behaviour.
Promotion, perks and other privileges
In truth, it can be difficult to disguise the fact that you prefer one individual to another. Often, the way managers interact with different employees day to day can speak volumes about who is the favourite; perhaps they are more flexible with them when they need time off, allow them to pick their own shifts, select them to help you with tasks, or simply laugh at their jokes more. In many cases, this isn’t a conscious choice, but these small acts of favouritism will almost certainly be picked up by other members of staff, and it’s important to be mindful of how this might come across.
But is this sort of unequal treatment illegal? The answer is, in some cases. The law doesn’t prohibit poor management practices or general unfairness, and favouring one employee over another based on their personality, work ethic, or even connection to you (if they are a relative or a friend of a friend) isn’t illegal. However, favouritism may be illegal if it takes the form of discrimination, harassment, or other mistreatment that violates the law.
Importantly, if preferential treatment is motivated by a protected characteristic, such as age, race or sex, then there is scope for aggrieved employees to bring a claim. For example, providing training opportunities for a 20-something employee and not for an employee in their fifties could constitute age discrimination. Similarly, promoting only people of a certain race, regardless of their ability, is likely to invite claims for race discrimination.
Not illegal, but not wise either
Whether acts of favouritism are illegal (related to a protected characteristic) or not, it is nonetheless a poor management move. Preferential treatment towards certain members of staff, from allowing them to pick their own shifts to openly praising them in front of others, is a sure-fire way to create resentment. Over time, realising that the favoured employee will continue to be rewarded regardless of what they do will cause other employees to stop trying, become disengaged, and even quit. All of this means that morale will take a hit, working relationships will suffer, and productivity will nose dive – and legal issues aside, that’s not good for business.
Letting employees get away with murder
If an employee violates any of your rules, whether through poor conduct, persistent lateness, or simply not showing up, it’s important to enforce your policies in a fair and consistent way. Consistently turning a blind eye to one employee’s misdemeanours while taking a heavy-handed approach towards another employee for the same offence is never a good idea, as it may cause mutiny within your team, undermine managers’ authority, and leave you exposed to legal risk.
Claims arising from unequal treatment are reasonably common. Failure to apply your policies fairly and consistently can result in unfair dismissal claim, and while each case will turn on its facts (for example, there may be mitigating factors that mean the circumstances in question aren’t entirely comparable), it’s never wise to run that risk. Again, there is a fine line between favouritism and discrimination, and if the person bringing a claim possesses a protected characteristic, the burden of proof may well fall on you to demonstrate that this played no part in your decision to treat them differently, and this can sometimes be difficult to evidence.
Even if you are successful in defending a claim, with the average case demanding, on average, 20 hours of employers’ time (or 60 to 80 hours when attendance at Tribunal as a witness is factored in), the costs of favouritism can be significant.
Legal risk aside, treating one member of staff as if they can do no wrong will strongly undermine managers’ abilities to enforce rules. After all, if you or one of your managers decides not to reprimand a favoured employee for failing to turn up to a shift without reasonable explanation, then your hands will be tied if others choose to follow suit. This will limit other managers’ options when it comes to managing them team effectively, which may prompt them to submit a grievance, or worse, feel they have no option but to resign as they have no authority to carry out their role properly. With this comes the potential for constructive dismissal claims.
Practical ways to combat favouritism in your workplace
As an employer, the stability of your team is vital, and if employees feel that they are being unfairly treated, there’s a high chance they will go elsewhere. With this in mind, there are a number of practical steps you can take to ensure favouritism doesn’t create animosity, push people out the door, or invite Employment Tribunal claims.
Employee issues causing disruption and taking time away from what you should be doing?
When you run a business or organisation, the stability of your team is vital. If employee relations issues are distracting attention away from key objectives, putting a strain on working relationships and hampering productivity, our highly-qualified HR and Employment Law Advisers can guide you through difficult matters quickly and compliantly.